Now into its 93rd season of existence the NHL has seen hundreds of legendary players grace rinks throughout North America. Since those earliest days, fans have identified the players they cheer for by the numbers on the back of their sweater. Some players were so great their numbers ended up retired by their respective clubs and now hang in the rafters of the arenas they played in so new fans can share in a history they never got to witness personally. Coming up with this list was an interesting challenge. In certain cases choosing the greatest NHL player by a specific number was dead simple. Numbers 99 and 66 are two examples. Other numbers had only one or two potential candidates, so they were quick to check off the list. Certain numbers were a much greater challenge, however. Numbers 9 and 19 each had a plethora of candidates, and required much deliberation before I finally settled. I suspect there will be many who disagree with my decisions. In the end that is half the fun in creating these posts – for the debate they are certain to spark. Read on for my picks for the greatest NHL players by the numbers they wore:
0 - Neil Sheehy
Right off the bat I get an easy one. Yes, John Davidson and Martin Biron both wore 00 early in their careers, but I decided to go with the single digit for this selection. Neil Sheehy is the only player in history to wear 0, doing so as a member of the Hartford Whalers. Not exactly a household name, but hey, with no competition what can you do?
1 – Jacques Plante
Only on my second selection and already I had my first challenge. Many people would have taken former shutout king Terry Sawchuk, and would certainly have a compelling reason for doing so. For my money, Plante got the nod (barely). Not only did he popularize the goalie mask he also won 7 Vezina Trophies (including 5 straight), a Hart Trophy (a rare feat for a goalie), and helped the Montreal Canadiens win an NHL record 5 straight Stanley Cups from 1956-1960.
2 - Doug Harvey
Three selections in and I’ve already got two Habs legends. Well, they are the most successful franchise in NHL history so it really shouldn’t be a big surprise. Before a guy named Bobby Orr came along, Harvey held the record for the most Norris Trophies with 7 and was widely considered the greatest defenseman to ever play the game.
3 - Pierre Pilote
Sandwiched right between the respective primes of Harvey and Orr came this Chicago Blackhawks all-star. Pilote was a key component of the powerful Blackhawks team that won the Stanley Cup in 1961 and he won three consecutive Norris Trophies between 1963 and 1965. While his 498 career points might pale against the totals of some of the other superstar defensemen on this list you have to remember that Pilote played in an era where d-men didn’t rack up a lot of points.
4 - Bobby Orr
Much like 66 and 99, the greatest player to ever wear #4 in the NHL isn’t in doubt. Bobby Orr dominated the game from the back end like no player before or since. He shattered numerous NHL records, many of which stand today. He helped his Boston Bruins win two Stanley Cups in the 1970s, scoring the Stanley Cup winning goal both times. He won 8 Norris Trophies and 3 Hart Trophies. The list of his amazing achievements go on and on, but perhaps the most incredible feat of Orr’s career was winning the Art Ross Trophy as the NHL’s leading scorer, not once, but twice! It is a tragedy that chronically bad knees forced him from the game he loved so early, otherwise it is quite likely that Orr’s name, not Gretzky’s would be the first mentioned when discussing the greatest players of all time.
Honorable Mention: Jean Beliveau - Yes 10 Stanley Cups, 2 Hart Trophies and 1,219 points are only good enough to merit HM status when matched up against Orr.
5 – Nicklas Lidstrom
Up until a few years ago, Denis Potvin would have been an easy choice for best NHL player to wear #5. However, one simply cannot ignore what Lidstrom has done during his tenure with the Detroit Red Wings. His 6 Norris Trophies are the third most in history, behind only Orr and Harvey, and he has been a key part of the powerful Red Wings squad that has won 4 cups between 1997 and today, including in 2008 when he made NHL history by becoming the first European-born player to captain his team to a Stanley Cup.
6 - Larry Aurie
The Detroit Red Wings have seen many superstars grace their roster. From Gordie Howe and Terry Sawchuk to Steve Yzerman and Nicklas Lidstrom this “Original Six” franchise has been a home to some of the biggest NHL legends past and present. Gordie Howe might be the team’s most famous star, but he wasn’t the first. The #6 hanging from the rafters of the Joe Louis Arena belongs to a player that donned a Wings jersey well before Howe’s time. Larry Aurie was a star two-way forward for the club, and helped the franchise win their first two Stanley Cups. Despite being a defensive standout, Aurie had no trouble putting the puck in the net, and his 23 goals were the most in the NHL during the 1936-37 season.
Honorable Mention: Phil Housley - One of the greatest offensive defensemen of all time, with more than 1,200 career points. Only Housley’s questionable defensive game kept him from this spot.
7 - Howie Morenz
He’s been called “the best ice hockey player of the first half of the 20th century”, and the “Babe Ruth of hockey”. He was dubbed the “Stratford Streak” for his incredible speed and his dazzling rushes up the ice. In many minds he was the first true NHL superstar, and it is little surprise to find this Montreal Canadiens’ legend listed as the best player to ever wear #7. He played during an era where forward passing was illegal and so end to end rushes were much more common. No one could rush the puck like Morenz, and much like Rocket Richard and Pavel Bure he could pull fans right out of their seats with his electrifying play. In 550 career games he scored 271 goals, including 40 in 44 games in 1929-30, and when the Hockey Hall of Fame opened in 1945 he was one of the original 12 inductees.
Honorable Mention: Phil Esposito - With 717 goals, 1,590 points and as one of only a handful of players to score 70+ goals and 150+ points in a single season Espo certainly gives Morenz a run for the money as the greatest #7 of all time.
8 - Teemu Selänne
#8 was another tough decision for me, but ultimately the “Finnish Flash” earned the nod. Selanne annihilated the record book when he burst on the NHL scene in 1992-93. In his rookie year with the Winnipeg Jets he potted a jaw-dropping 76 goals, smashing Mike Bossy’s record for goals by a rookie by 23. His 132 points were also 23 more than Peter Stastny’s previous mark for points by a rookie. Selanne would earn the Calder Trophy in a landslide. Though he has never duplicated that remarkable first season, Selanne has continued to put up impressive numbers throughout his career, twice more topping 50 goals and twice more eclipsing 100 points as a member of the Anaheim Ducks. With 613 career goals and counting Selanne has more goals than any other Finnish-born player in NHL history, including legend Jari Kurri.
Honorable Mention: Cam Neely, Alexander Ovechkin - As great as Selanne is this choice wasn’t a slam dunk. Neely is a Hall of Famer, one of the greatest power forwards of all time, and one of just a handful of players to score 50 goals in 50 games or less. Ovechkin’s career is only in its infancy, yet already he’s established his legend. With a pair of Hart Trophies, a Calder Trophy and an Art Ross Trophy already under his belt, this Russian superstar will quite likely one day be considered “The Greatest 8”.
9 – Gordie Howe
No shortage of competition for this number, but “Mr. Hockey” takes the title of best player to ever wear #9. Howe is not only one of the most skilled players of all time, he is also one of its most feared. Unlike other stars Howe needed no one to protect him. His left and right elbows took care of that quite well. Howe was the dominant player of his era, nabbing 6 NHL scoring titles and adding 6 Hart Trophies for good measure. At the time of his retirement he was the all time leader in goals (801), assists (1,049) and points (1,850) despite spending two years in retirement and another 6 years in the WHA.
Honorable Mention: Maurice “The Rocket” Richard, Bobby Hull - What can you say about these two legends? The Rocket was as determined a goal scorer as the NHL has ever seen, and was the first player to score 50 goals in a season (doing so in 50 games), 500 goals in a career, and is to this day the Montreal Canadiens’ all time leading goal scorer with 544. Hull was another pure scorer, whose combination of speed, strength and unparalleled shot made him nearly unstoppable. He scored even more goals than Richard (610) despite spending 7 years with the Winnipeg Jets of the WHA.
